Back to articles

Fundraising

How to Ask Major Donors for More Without Freezing Up

Written by Sandy Hilsenrath Last updated: November 20, 20268 min read

The $2,500 Coffee That Taught Julie a Lesson

Julie Ordoñez has helped raise $65 million over 16 years, and one of the stories she tells on the Hey Nonprofits! podcast is about a gift she got right and an ask she got wrong. Early in her career she finally landed a 30-minute coffee with the managing partner of a major firm in downtown Los Angeles. She was around 25, nervous, and worried about asking for too much. When the moment came she asked whether he would consider $2,500.

She still remembers his face. It dropped. He said sure, opened his briefcase, wrote the check, wished her luck and left. Julie sat there sweating through her suit and realized she had wasted his time. He was ready to do much more, and she had not been brave enough to say so, or informed enough about who she was talking to.

Her takeaway is the line that should be taped above every development director's desk: you can damage a relationship by asking for too little. The donor does not know your need better than you do. If you ask for $2,500, you are telling them that $2,500 is all you need from them.

Asking for More Is Part of the Job

Julie coaches fundraisers through her program Nonprofit Courage Lab, and she shared a recent example. A development manager asked a board member to raise his annual gift from $10,000 to $15,000. That is not a radical increase, and it came from a board member. His reaction was to tell her not to get too greedy over there.

Julie's advice was to answer with the reason for the ask: we are asking for more because we are growing our impact. If that offends a board member, this may not be the right seat for him. Her view is blunt. If a donor assumes your extra $5,000 is going to a jet ski, that is their projection, not your behavior. And learning it now beats learning it later.

Two things stand out here. First, the staff member did not take the comment as a verdict on her worth. She called her coach and got a script. Second, the ask came attached to the thing the donor cares about, the growth of the mission. Money is the tool, impact is the reason.

Tie the number to what it makes possible. Donors push back on a vague ask. They rarely push back on a specific one with a reason.

Most Wealth Is Not Sitting in Cash

Julie calls one of her early lessons the invisible millions. When you run donors through a wealth screening tool, she explained, it returns a rating, and nearly every nonprofit has at least one person with a net worth of $5 million or more. But most of that wealth is not cash in the bank. When she learned from a mentor at United Way how to talk with donors about giving from their wealth, not just from their checking account, she found the gift could be 10 to 15 times larger than a typical cash gift.

The time investment is the same. It takes the same effort to get the meeting, make the call and send the email. What changes is the size of the conversation. Her point is not that every donor holds a stock portfolio. It is that fundraisers who only ever ask for what a credit card can cover will only ever get what a credit card can cover.

Say the Ask, Say the Number, Then Stop Talking

Host Trevor Nelson has a sales background, and he asked Julie about the oldest trick in the book: silence. Her instruction is simple. Make the ask, say the number, stop talking, and wait for the donor to respond. Whatever they say, have a Plan A, B, C and D ready.

She also gave a useful reply to a common objection. Donors will sometimes say that their philanthropic dollars are accounted for this year. That used to leave her speechless. Now she says it is great that they plan in advance, and since they are already thinking about their giving, can they talk about next year? Julie has said this to extremely wealthy people, and they often react as though she is prepared and respects their time.

Preparation builds trust. She gave an example of what that sounds like: restating what the donor said they care about, why that ties to your goal, and then a specific number over a specific time, like $150,000 over two years toward a goal of impacting a million people by 2030. You are not guessing. You are repeating back what they told you.

Yes, You Can Ask Too Soon. Here's What to Do Next

Julie did not pretend she has never mistimed an ask. She told the story of a man who came to one event, connected through the board chair, and who she asked for a quarter of a million dollars. His first response was that it felt soon. She was mortified.

What she did next is the lesson. She owned it and apologized. He explained that his friend the board chair had been involved for around 20 years, that he did not need 20 years, but a year seemed right. He wanted to come to another event, bring his wife, and see what the organization did around the holidays. It was not off the table. It was a timeline.

So the real skill is not avoiding a miss. It is reading where you stand with someone. Julie said donors move at different speeds. Some need a year or a year and a half. Some need one meeting, a look at the annual report and the board list, and they are ready. Her coaching is to ask what the donor's next step is, and how you can help them take it.

Face the Awkward With Lapsed Donors

This is where the episode got its title. Julie believes fundraisers chase new donors in part because they dropped the ball with the ones they already had and would rather start fresh than face them. Her phrase for the fix is to acknowledge the awkward.

If a donor has gone quiet, you can say so. Julie has told donors that the organization failed them, even when it happened before she arrived and was not her fault. The donor does not care that you are new. They are dealing with the organization. So own it, do what you can to make it right, and make that outreach part of your job. Her read is that donors tend to be more forgiving than you expect.

And if someone cannot let it go, she says to let them go, because there are plenty of other people searching for the problem you solve in the way you solve it. Hanging on to people who are bitter is a quick way to lower your own confidence.

That connects to a fear many readers will recognize, the belief that you cannot call a donor who stopped giving. Julie's answer is that the awkwardness is the price of the conversation, and it is smaller than the cost of an unanswered lapse.

Thank First-Time Donors Quickly, in a Way You Will Actually Do

Trevor asked about gratitude, and Julie started with timing. She cited data, which she admitted she recalled loosely, that thanking first-time donors within 48 hours significantly increases the chance of a second gift. And a thank-you call from a board member, with no ask attached, boosts it even more. It also gets board members involved in fundraising in a way they enjoy.

Then she said something refreshing. The best stewardship method is the one you will actually do. One of her clients raised over $10 million in 2024 with an 86% major donor retention rate. He hates writing handwritten notes, which Julie loves. So he records quick, personalized Loom videos, under five minutes, walking a donor through the annual report or a page on the website. Her point is that energy shows. If you hate emails, do not write emails. Pick the format you enjoy, and you will be consistent.

Money Flows Through Relationships

A theme under the whole conversation is listening. Julie said she has had success because she listens longer than most people are willing to, and hears what donors tell nobody else. She also said that many wealthy people are looking for meaning and connection. They have the house and the success and want to do something that lasts. Nonprofits discount that, she said, and it is a real advantage.

She practices this with the same empathy at every level of wealth. They are people with flat tires and sick relatives. Her line to clients is that you are not coming for their money, you are coming for their whole life, meaning their time, introductions and calls, in addition to a gift. When a donor's values align with yours, she asks, why stop with the check.

She also described the thinking that holds many fundraisers back. In her words, we believe we have to figure it out alone, that we should be further along than we are, and that we should absorb the slack from team members and board members by adding more to our own plate. Asked by Trevor what makes fundraising harder than it needs to be, she answered with two words: doing it alone. Raising money is a form of asking for help, she said, and if you struggle to ask for help in your personal life, it will show up in your work.

What to Do This Week

You can borrow several moves from Julie's story without hiring anyone. Pull your top 15 donors and look at what you asked for last time. For any who gave readily and without negotiation, ask whether you asked for too little. Draft a specific ask with a number, a timeline and a reason, and practice saying the number and stopping.

If you want a low-pressure way to build the habit, borrow the format Julie uses with her group: a 10-asks-in-10-days challenge. The ask does not have to be for money. It can be for help, or for a conversation you have been putting off. Her members report in at the end of each day, and her first question after any win is what they learned from it. She says the most common answer is that it was simpler than they made it out to be.

Then make a short list of lapsed donors you have avoided out of embarrassment. Pick one and send a note that acknowledges the gap. Finally, decide on your thank-you medium, whether that is a quick video, a call or a note, and set a 48-hour rule for first-time donors.

You do not need a better script as much as you need a reason to believe the donor wants to hear from you. Julie's experience says they usually do.

Insights in this article are drawn from the Hey Nonprofits! podcast “Your Best Donors Already Exist (Here's How to Get Them Back)”, featuring fundraising coach Julie Ordoñez.

About the author

Sandy Hilsenrath, Community Engagement and Content Manager

Sandy Hilsenrath

Community Engagement and Content Manager

With almost 2 decades working for nonprofits, Sandy brings perspective and understanding of what it takes to raise money for today's nonprofits.